Case notes

How to actually read a custody case (without a law degree)

This post is for general information only and isn't legal advice. Family law is fact-specific — if you're dealing with a real situation, please speak to a qualified, regulated solicitor.

[Starter post — this is a framework, not a write-up of a real case. Replace the walkthrough below with the actual judgment you want to cover, and double-check every fact and citation before publishing.]

Family court judgments can be dense, but you don't need a law degree to follow the shape of one. Here's what I look for.

1. What was actually being decided

Most children-related judgments in England and Wales sit under the Children Act 1989. Start by pinning down the specific order the court was asked to make — a child arrangements order, a specific issue order, or a prohibited steps order, for example. That framing changes what the rest of the judgment means.

2. The welfare checklist

Courts weigh a set list of factors known as the welfare checklist — things like the child's own wishes and feelings (given their age and understanding), their physical and emotional needs, and the likely effect of any change in circumstances. Judgments usually work through these explicitly, so it's worth reading for how each factor was weighed, not just the final outcome.

3. Why the outcome, not just what it was

The headline result matters less than the court's reasoning. Two cases with similar facts can land differently depending on the specific evidence in front of the judge — so a judgment is a data point about how the law was applied, not a fixed rule for every family in a similar position.

4. Where to find real judgments

If you want to follow real cases, the National Archives' Find Case Law service and the Family Court's published judgments are good places to start — always read the judgment itself before relying on someone else's summary, including mine.

Case write-ups on this blog are commentary, not legal advice, and shouldn't be treated as a substitute for reading the judgment or taking advice on a specific situation.

← More in Case notes